get a Rhinehart! they are awesome! they have a self healing foam that works great, makes it a lil hard to get arrows out, but they last for years! after all they are able to garentee the 18-1 target for a year that you cant wear it out, me and my friend tried WITH BROAD HEADS to wear it out, we didnt even get 1/2 of it worn out in a year of shooting almost every day!
you cant go wrong with one, and the bow hunter buck can be had for around $175 and it will last longer so you'll be saving money.
(I also shoot the R-100, a 100 target 3d shoot put on by Rinehart)
this shows you that I belive in Rinehart targets-