I'd take the Black Ice personally. We fianally got an Iceman into work the other day and I got to shoot it. It did get 277 fps all setup at 60 lbs which is cooking. On the other hand it has an aggressive came to get there so the pull is hard but smooth. After the shot there was a surprising amount of vibration. Not hand shock, but more of a twang that rings for a little bit. It's a slick shooting bow though and it's the best bow I've shot without a sight. If you want a smoother, easier to draw bow, then I say Black Ice.
As for stuff to put on it. I like the limbsaver S-coil stabilizers. They get the job done fine and don't cost an arm and a leg. For front sights I like the Tru Glo Tooless series. I like not having to use an allen wrench to move the gang adjustments. For a peep I like the G5 meta peep, no more speed robbing rubber tubing. Finally for the rest, I don't skimp here. The rest of the stuff was cheap, but I spend some money on my rest and I recommend an Octane Hostage Pro. The regular hostage has had a bunch of problems with stripping and mis-sizing since it's made of plastic. The Pro is all aluminum. The big deal with it is a full capture rest but unlike the whisker biscuit it doesn't tear up your fletchings, there are gaps for them to go through.
I reckon that wraps it up for me.