Duck Hunting Forum banner
1 - 20 of 29 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,182 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
THinking of a wirehair. Only problem is that I hear they will only hunt for one person period. I think a pointing lab carries around too much weight to hunt all day quail hunting.

I am looking for a pointing dog and a good retriever. Our brittany would be the best of both worlds if he could learn to hold his points. Also hate taking him out when it is really cold.

Any ideas? Is there a breed out there I am missing?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
378 Posts
i have a weimarianer and a choco lab. both are great dogs. both retrieve and both will point.. My lab is actually pointing better than my pointer right now. If i had to chose between the 2 i would go for the lab. the weim just doesnt have the coat to put up with the cold weather. Alot of people bash the weims but i think alot of mine. I wouldnt trade her for any other kind of pointer. just my thoughts
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
204 Posts
Same here. My weimaraner is awesome in the field. I took her duck hunting this morning...she wouldn't hold still and kept whining when I would call. She's pretty new at the duck hunting as am I, but it was still pretty frustrating. She also doesnt handle the cold very well, especially when wet...so I would have to second that weimaraners would not make very good duck hunters.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,850 Posts
Wirehair sounds like a good choice too me. Great upland and can stand the cold a whole lot better than other upland breeds. Make sure you talk to the breeder to see about the dog's coat though. Since you are a big duck hunter you're going to want a good thick coat. Not all wire's have as thick of coats as others. This could also be my next dog since I'm getting into duck hunting more.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,344 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
233 Posts
The GWP or Drahthaar would be a good dog for what you want. If you consider this dog I would strongly suggest you take the time to research both of the breeds. THEY ARE TWO SEPERATE BREEDS. I currently have a GSP and have a drahthaar puppy on the way--will be mine in two months. I decided on a drahthaar because I do alot of upland and just as much duck. The gsp isnt as wild about the ducks in 10 degree weather as I am so I needed a dog that I know will handle whatever temp I decide to go in.

MAKE SURE YOU DO THE RESEARCH AND FULLY UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU ARE GETTING.

98-if you are looking for more info on the drahthaar you can PM me and I will go through everything that I have learned in the past two years of research GOOD AND BAD
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,027 Posts
mfetter- I have two young dogs right now but in a year or so I might be ready to buy a dh. I have heard they are nothing short of amazing. They run the field like a shorthair and push ice for geese like a chessy. Almost sounds too good to be true?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
233 Posts
They are both of those, but most will rip one arm off give it back to you then go for the other. I am young and have no kids and am getting married soon, and starting my own business so I was looking for a protective dog that would cater to both my upland and duck hunting needs---after TONS of research the drahthaars were my final decision. They do come with their flaws, just like every dog, but there are many amazing aspects to them as well. Again make sure you fully understand what you are getting if you decide to go with one.

:mrgreen:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
40 Posts
Get a German shorthair point and retrieve upland birds and love water although I haven't taken mine duck hunting because he is only 5 months and i want to make sure he hunts well on upland birds which so far he does great he pointed quail at 4 months and retrieves everything plus he does exactly what I tell him almost all the time. Plus thier cheap to mine was only $40 although the guy wanted $100 but he was my neighbor so he gave me a deal. but I've never heard of people wanting over $200 except for show dogs.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
233 Posts
YOU HAVENT HEARD OF SOMEONE ASKING MORE THAN 200 FOR A SHORTHAIR :eek: -----I would look at anyone breeding and testing through NAVHDA 200 would be a deal. Almost anyone that breeds shorthairs and has proven lines though most any type of testing would ask more than 200.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,850 Posts
$40 dollars is truly unbelievable! $100 is unbelievable! I have seen shorthairs without AKC papers go for $150. I'll say just the opposite that you did. I have never seen any registered shorthairs for under $350. If your neighbors sire and dam are both registered dogs with any kind of hunting abilities, then he is getting ripped off.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
14,647 Posts
The Boykin, GWP or Drahthaar sound like good choices. Upland and Water don't typically mix well. I own both a GSP and Labs.

The GSPs are great dogs, but are not made for the cold at all. Their short coats and light body structures suit them well for covering the fields and not overheating. I would never put mine in cold water and expect her to sit still.

On the other hand, my labs have been wonderful water dogs. When the temperatures dip, I put neoprene on them just to make sure they stay comfortable, but forget about them in the upland. They will go and try, but if the temperature goes up at all (above 45 degrees), there is a real risk of heat stroke. Kind of like taking an offensive lineman for a day long run.

Hopefully, it will be many years before I look for a new dog, but when that time comes, I will definitely look into the dogs mentioned here.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Having owned and trained both, I would go with the dog that suits the majority of your hunting best, yet can get the other job done as well.
I flat out love GWP's, but they will never match a Lab in the marsh. I have seen some very nice Pointing Labs, but they are a poor second to GWP's when it comes to quail.
If you hunt waterfowl the most, go with the PL, if it is upland you do the most, go with the GWP.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
109 Posts
I have a lab but use my GSHP "Mojoman" for birding and is my #1 waterfowl retreiver until the freezing water temps and ice occurs. He loves it. One thing I will mention, I DO NOT have my GSHP tails cropped if I'm going to use them for waterfowling, . . . like any water dog, they use it as a "rudder".

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
135 Posts
A pudlepointer (thats where the wirehair comes from) Jameson Parker from A dogs life on tv owns them. A drathaar and a wirehair are the same breed no matter what some people think. Check with the registery in Germany
 
1 - 20 of 29 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top