Heres your best bet. Go buy 1-2 dozen of each brand. Use them each the same amount and deciede which works and looks the best after each season. I think I have tried almost all of them. I am like a woman when it comes to purses or shoes. I am just man that can't get enough decoys. I personally after using the avery pealers, and the xps leakers. I have resorted back to old faithful the Flambeau Magnum Weighted keel. They may not always look the prettiest out of the box, but they sure hold up the best for me after a few years. Plus they stand bye there product Unlike G&H. I bought 4Doz G&H Goose Floaters a few years back, and had 11 leakers before the early goose season was over with. They were all leaking from the round seal in the butt. G&H replaced them 10 out of 11 that didn't make it another week. Thats when I talked to the owner of G&H at the Shot Show in LV a couple years ago, he basicly said "sucks to be you" and walked away from me. Thats when I decieded throw all my G&H away. You basicly got to go with whatever brand you feel comfortable with and you feel comfortable with.