Duck Hunting Forum banner
1 - 20 of 21 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
54 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Do you think spinning wing decoys should be outlawed?
Yes1438.89%
No1952.78%
Depends on the area/state/situation38.33%
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
54 Posts
Discussion Starter · #2 ·
Well, I don't mean to stir the pot, but I've been reading a lot lately on other sites about getting rid of the spinning wing decoys and I've come back with info from both sides.

For the people who want to get rid of the spinning wing decoys they see them as an eyesore. They are taking away the heritage from hunting and creating more difficulty for other hunters who don't have the money to get them or just don't want them. Also, it is making the ducks "wise up" faster, creating greater difficulty for everyone.

On the other hand, for those people in favor of keeping the spinning wing decoys, they say they are a needed addition to any decoy spread. It greatly increases the chances of bagging birds and adds enjoyment to the hunt. Also, they believe that to those hunters who don't like them, that is their own problem and they should adapt and move on.

In either case I see a lot of room for debate. I honestly don't know what my side is. I like using the spinning wing decoys because they produce well, but it seems that the ducks are wisening up anyway. Also, when there is more pressure I can see how it would be an unfair advantage to other hunters. Of course there is the statement "every hunter for himself..."
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
135 Posts
my buddy who's a bio said the duck limit is based on a worst case senario and it wont hurt duck numbers to use them even if they do help you shoot more. In our state not one single state bio voted to ban them but our game comission did it anyway.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,708 Posts
I voted to ban them. It has been said on many other duck hunting sites, but I feel that it gives people a crutch to lean on. People that haven't bothered to do their homework (or haven't had time) like finding where the birds actually want to be, decoy placement or calling are able to kill as many birds as someone who has been hunting ducks for 20 years.

I'm not knocking anyone who uses them because I use them myself. However, I use them as a way to level the playing field on the weekends. When I'm lucky enough to get a few weekdays off I won't use a spinner and still shoot the same amount of birds.

yeller
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,182 Posts
ol' yeller said:
I voted to ban them. It has been said on many other duck hunting sites, but I feel that it gives people a crutch to lean on. People that haven't bothered to do their homework (or haven't had time) like finding where the birds actually want to be, decoy placement or calling are able to kill as many birds as someone who has been hunting ducks for 20 years.

I'm not knocking anyone who uses them because I use them myself. However, I use them as a way to level the playing field on the weekends. When I'm lucky enough to get a few weekdays off I won't use a spinner and still shoot the same amount of birds.

yeller
couldn't have said it any better myself.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
345 Posts
success early in any endeaver can keep the attention of newbies. why take away the opportunity to create a duck hunter. my way may not be the same a yours, but that doesn't make it wrong. I'll be using jerk strings all year long. Are you going to outlaw them too?

John
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,091 Posts
I personally think that the Feds should ban them nation wide. It does indeed give a person an advantage to when using them from first hand experience. My bag has not gone up, but then again I usually average 4 ducks for hunt. I t just took a little longer before than now with the spinner. But for the marginal hunter-that is a different story. Some guys go a put out 1 dz decoys and maybe get 1 birds per person, now they throw out a spinner and get 2 to 3 per person-and many hunters are marginal, so the the sheer number of additional birds being bagged has increased. Are live decoys, more than 3 shells in a gun, 8 ga guns, etc... any more effective than a spinners-and yet they were banned over 70 years ago. Where do you draw the line on fair chase? Heck many hunters are seeing the new enemy as Mud Motors being they are so loud and are chasing the birds out of their hiding places-and when you bust the roost-they leave., so many are upset with them. Heck I remember 25 years ago the average OBmotor was a 10hp, now it is 30hp for duck hunting. The bottom line is there have been many technological advances over the last 20 years, MMs, Spinners, Goretex, Bigger boats/motors and more of them, etc... Maybe it it time to start restricting some of this. So the spinner should go IMHO as it is a reasonable start.

I now AR will be banning them for '05 and heard a rumor IL will too next year. PA, OR, WA are already banned and Calif and Mn has partial bans in effect this year.

The Feds need to get a backbone and stand of for the ducks and the sport and ban the spinners.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,182 Posts
h2ofwlr said:
I personally think that the Feds should ban them nation wide. It does indeed give a person an advantage to when using them from first hand experience. My bag has not gone up, but then again I usually average 4 ducks for hunt. I t just took a little longer before than now with the spinner. But for the marginal hunter-that is a different story. Some guys go a put out 1 dz decoys and maybe get 1 birds per person, now they throw out a spinner and get 2 to 3 per person-and many hunters are marginal, so the the sheer number of additional birds being bagged has increased. Are live decoys, more than 3 shells in a gun, 8 ga guns, etc... any more effective than a spinners-and yet they were banned over 70 years ago. Where do you draw the line on fair chase? Heck many hunters are seeing the new enemy as Mud Motors being they are so loud and are chasing the birds out of their hiding places-and when you bust the roost-they leave., so many are upset with them. Heck I remember 25 years ago the average OBmotor was a 10hp, now it is 30hp for duck hunting. The bottom line is there have been many technological advances over the last 20 years, MMs, Spinners, Goretex, Bigger boats/motors and more of them, etc... Maybe it it time to start restricting some of this. So the spinner should go IMHO as it is a reasonable start.

I now AR will be banning them for '05 and heard a rumor IL will too next year. PA, OR, WA are already banned and Calif and Mn has partial bans in effect this year.

The Feds need to get a backbone and stand of for the ducks and the sport and ban the spinners.
I whole heartedly agree
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
598 Posts
I say let everyone keep using them because it helps me when I'm the only one not using one and I kill all the ducks :toofunny: Seriously, I could care less if they were banned or not, I have one but don't even use it because when I have, it flares the ducks. I killed my limit almost every day last year without it. And everyone around me used them and they didn't kill near as many as I did. Think about it, when the ducks fly all the way down the U.S. most of the setups they see have a robo in it. So by the time they get down here to TN they know that when they see those spinning wings, it's not a good sign. I agree with Ol Yeller, good calling and good decoy placement are what kill ducks! :salude:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
68 Posts
I've never hunted over one so my opinion is biased,but I don't feel the need to ban anything because once it starts they will be banning all kinds of stuff , i.e. wobbler dekes, maybe some duck call will work to good and they'll ban it too. Just give the birds time to adjust they'll all learn and it'll be another gimmick that worked for a while. I've seen new fishing lures come out and catch alot of fish and the next year you couldn't buy a bite on them. but just drop back to the old standbys and you'll be right back in da game. I know many people tell me they are awsome and work great, but I have just as many ducks in my hand if not more. The people that seem to like them the most are new to duck hunting so let'em get hooked on the sport. I would say the robo duck thing isn't going to last much longer and the ducks won't give'em anything more than a distant glance and flare off. If ya want to save more ducks from unnesasary death find a way to stop people from sky-busting and wounding too many ducks that fly away to die! Besides I don't understand why it's a big deal the limit here is six birds robo duck or no robo duck you only get six if it'll help bring'em in closer for quick clean kills thats less wounded ducks in my opinion.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
935 Posts
I'm an old timer and don't really like them, BUT I love it when other guys have used them over the past couple years. Birds in my area are nearly scared to death of them, even the flight birds shy away. Nice idea that's past it's prime.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
40 Posts
Hi All

They work much too good---the gripe is that some so called hunters will limit out every day --without the robo they might only get 2 birds--now the greedy you know whats ,are making sausage 24 hr a day.

One of our hunters passed away and we found two freezers full of ducks / geese--200 ducks--125 geese

The advantage is one can enjoy a true hunt for 1 or 2 hours and go home with a few birds without spending a whole day out there.Some of the old retired guys are going to ruin it for all of us.

YEP,MEBBE THEY SHOULD BE BANNED!!

TOM
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
729 Posts
I say we keep 'em.

I don't care if it gives a less "seasoned" hunter an advantage.
Not everyone has access to the internet, a family history of hunting or friends to show them the art of hunting.

I encourage new hunters and the mojo and robo ducks help them enjoy the hunt. Ducks are smart, the mojo really only works well for me for about 2-3 weeks. Then it is back to old school.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,182 Posts
Little Lesson I learned Yesterday

We went to hunt the spot we scouted out the day before only to find another guy had just beat us to it (cause we sheared a pin and did some wild stuff to make a new one). Anyways, we set up about 150 yards from him in a location we deemed less than ideal so we didn't ruin his hunt. THe way the birds were going in the night before we figured he would be done in short order and then we would move in. He was doing it old school with no Mojo and a jerk string. We put out 3 dozen decoys with 3 Mojo Mallards (would've been 5 if the parts would come in). He killed one hen that we let live. Every duck that came in tried to land next to the mojos. These ducks see extreme hunting pressure, and we kill them over them all year long. The only reason we bought them is to keep up with the competition.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
378 Posts
Hey Ks, i was reading all the post on this topic and saw 2 post that you looked to be against the flippy ducks, but as i read on you offer another post that says you used 3 but woulda had 5 if you had parts... really doesnt matter to me but found it kinda funny a guy who was against 'em would use as many as 5.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,182 Posts
I am completely against them, but on our marsh without them you may as well go home. Too many city guyd who hunt 2 times a year bring out 8 and pull them off of the guys who scouted. I hate the damn things, but if I wanna kill birds I gotta have em.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,621 Posts
we have spinners. we dont use them much anymore. dont seem to be as affective as they use to be.if somebody wants to use them why not.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,919 Posts
it would appear that KS is doing exactly what folks have mentioned....it was a crutch to get birds away from standard hunting practices.....I wonder what you could have done going mano-a-mano with the other guy.....just with standard dekes and calling.....I mean, KS, you even admit it, it was because of a spinner that you scored

and what's up with posting that you are for banning...then you use a bunch to blow-off ducks from a guy in the right place..... and take ducks you didn't deserve! and lastly....you set up within 150 yards....so you really were trying to pull birds from their normal flight practices.....ever hear of or believe in ethics?! If it was a 'controlled' experiment with all parties, that would have been a cool test...but you stroked some guy and now brag.

It can't be both ways!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,182 Posts
Just showing you how effective they were. We were in the second spot they wanted to be in. We gave him 150 yard cushion which is 3 times as much as anybody else gives us. If the birds were working him we let em work him without calling them off. We didn't shoot his swing birds either like he shot at ours a couple of times. I would much rather scout than use my mojos next year. I hope every state bans them *** forsaken things.

If you can't beat them join them.
 
1 - 20 of 21 Posts
Top