Never thought about it till i read about it last night. When on a hunt and you sail a bird and send them back. How do you give it the command to hunt by itsself vs having control of what there doing the whole time
That was my answer. You release it to hunt on it's own. Just like you would if you were releasing it from your side to go find birds.hillbilly.. said:That part i understand. I was referring to the comment you made in another topic. I cast my dog 100 150 yrds on a dead or crippled bird and i can get him in the general area. What or how do you tell the dog he is now on his own.
So the dog will know the old fall scent isn't the new fall scent when it crosses over it?Chaws said:Not necessary to have a command of its own. Most dogs will start to become out of control anyways once they get into an area of scent. Just give the last cast you want and see if the dog comes up with anything. A dog with a good nose is always "hunting" even when following casts on a blind, they're just under more control. Get the dog in the area or down wind and let them have at it.
No, a dog will drop their head on any scent cone or old fall. That's what training for casting through old falls does. Tweet, cast, continue to the next fall area. In a hunting situation I'd be hard pressed to know any human that can accurately mark a fall as well as a fair marking dog. Even if sent on a mark and the dog gets hung up in an old fall, tweet, cast, and the dog can continue deeper to the current fall.HNTFSH said:So the dog will know the old fall scent isn't the new fall scent when it crosses over it?Chaws said:Not necessary to have a command of its own. Most dogs will start to become out of control anyways once they get into an area of scent. Just give the last cast you want and see if the dog comes up with anything. A dog with a good nose is always "hunting" even when following casts on a blind, they're just under more control. Get the dog in the area or down wind and let them have at it.
When the dog gets to where I thought the bird was and doesn't come up with it, I stop him and use my upland command with a goofy arm signal to release him. They very well may be able to recognize and distinguish an old scent from a fresh one, they can recognize a back track. There is an awful lot about how dogs use their noses that we just don't know.Chaws said:No, a dog will drop their head on any scent cone or old fall. That's what training for casting through old falls does. Tweet, cast, continue to the next fall area. In a hunting situation I'd be hard pressed to know any human that can accurately mark a fall as well as a fair marking dog. Even if sent on a mark and the dog gets hung up in an old fall, tweet, cast, and the dog can continue deeper to the current fall.HNTFSH said:So the dog will know the old fall scent isn't the new fall scent when it crosses over it?Chaws said:Not necessary to have a command of its own. Most dogs will start to become out of control anyways once they get into an area of scent. Just give the last cast you want and see if the dog comes up with anything. A dog with a good nose is always "hunting" even when following casts on a blind, they're just under more control. Get the dog in the area or down wind and let them have at it.
I'd prefer for the sake of less whistling afield, to have the dog take the line until it's at the spot I want it to stop and release it. Maintaining the same principles for hunting and testing makes it all easier, in both.Chaws said:No, a dog will drop their head on any scent cone or old fall. That's what training for casting through old falls does. Tweet, cast, continue to the next fall area. In a hunting situation I'd be hard pressed to know any human that can accurately mark a fall as well as a fair marking dog. Even if sent on a mark and the dog gets hung up in an old fall, tweet, cast, and the dog can continue deeper to the current fall.HNTFSH said:So the dog will know the old fall scent isn't the new fall scent when it crosses over it?Chaws said:Not necessary to have a command of its own. Most dogs will start to become out of control anyways once they get into an area of scent. Just give the last cast you want and see if the dog comes up with anything. A dog with a good nose is always "hunting" even when following casts on a blind, they're just under more control. Get the dog in the area or down wind and let them have at it.
That's fine, a dog is a dog.Chaws said:Ok, lets set it up where you bounced a duck on the ground in some cover and I'd like to see your dog keep a line through it without them dropping their head and breaking stride. I run field trials and train with pros that have won nationals and even national caliber dogs will check up when they hit a heavy sent pocket.
Dropping it's head, stumbling across an old scent that gets the dogs attention afield is a lot different than 'out-of-control'. Field Trial set-ups and what's being tested is controlled. Hunting isn't.Chaws said:Not necessary to have a command of its own. Most dogs will start to become out of control anyways once they get into an area of scent. Just give the last cast you want and see if the dog comes up with anything.
This^. Chaws, we aren't talking about a FT blind where the bird stays put. In your example of giving the last cast you want, what happens when the dog comes up empty, either because the handler mis-marked it, or because it moved? At that point I give my dogs permission to honor their nose with a specific command. It hardly equates to "becoming out of control".HNTFSH said:That's fine, a dog is a dog.Chaws said:Ok, lets set it up where you bounced a duck on the ground in some cover and I'd like to see your dog keep a line through it without them dropping their head and breaking stride. I run field trials and train with pros that have won nationals and even national caliber dogs will check up when they hit a heavy sent pocket.
That example is a little different than your first comment though:
Dropping it's head, stumbling across an old scent that gets the dogs attention afield is a lot different than 'out-of-control'. Field Trial set-ups and what's being tested is controlled. Hunting isn't.Chaws said:Not necessary to have a command of its own. Most dogs will start to become out of control anyways once they get into an area of scent. Just give the last cast you want and see if the dog comes up with anything.
That's my point. The dog having a clear objective, consistently, is what's important.
Who said anything about not carrying a cast? There is no cast in the situation I am describing unless the dog gets off the initial line. I understand what OofC means in a FT context, but as I said, I am giving the dog permission to hunt in specific circumstances. If he didn't get that permission, he had best not honor his nose.Chaws said:When sending a dog on a blind and then the dog honoring their nose is considered out of control. The dog is under their own control at that point when they're not following the line they were sent on. I'm having a hard time figuring out where the problem went in this conversation. I've trained my own MH titled and QAA first place dog and he's also picked up well over 2,000 birds in the wild here in Nodak. Point the dog into the area of the fall, get them down wind of the area and once the dog hits a scent cone, let em be and he'll come up with the bird. I judge field trials as well so maybe that's where the term out of control is confusing everyone here. The dog when not carrying a cast, whether that cast be a whistle or arm motion, is considered out of control in those venues.
I'd be careful with the word 'always' but by and large that works. If hunting birds in cover so heavy you can't see the dog, and the dog can't mark most falls, might wanna figure your shots different.Rick Hall said:Pretty nice that you guys hunt places where you can always see the dog to stop him and tell him to hunt 'em up.
I could have said, "often" or even "occasionally," instead of "always," and the point would have been the same: there are a great many hunting venues where one won't see the dog at the area of the fall to direct him, and one's best bet for recovering game is a dog that knows he's allowed to break down and hunt when his nose and/or experience suggests he do so.HNTFSH said:I'd be careful with the word 'always' but by and large that works. If hunting birds in cover so heavy you can't see the dog, and the dog can't mark most falls, might wanna figure your shots different.Rick Hall said:Pretty nice that you guys hunt places where you can always see the dog to stop him and tell him to hunt 'em up.
So are you saying that you would move off of the "x" to accommodate your dog?HNTFSH said:I'd be careful with the word 'always' but by and large that works. If hunting birds in cover so heavy you can't see the dog, and the dog can't mark most falls, might wanna figure your shots different.Rick Hall said:Pretty nice that you guys hunt places where you can always see the dog to stop him and tell him to hunt 'em up.
Insert plond barb here.Easttx said:So are you saying that you would move off of the "x" to accommodate your dog?HNTFSH said:I'd be careful with the word 'always' but by and large that works. If hunting birds in cover so heavy you can't see the dog, and the dog can't mark most falls, might wanna figure your shots different.Rick Hall said:Pretty nice that you guys hunt places where you can always see the dog to stop him and tell him to hunt 'em up.