Duck Hunting Forum banner

Electric collar?

4.6K views 18 replies 12 participants last post by  Ze6464  
#1 ·
What is everybody using? I don't need the most expensive one, unless it really is that much better. I think most of them are waterproof but that would be a necessity as well Any suggestions would be great!
 
#4 ·
Did some research over lunch...thinking about the sport dog 425. Looks like the 400 (discontinued now) had some problems but the 425 has better reviews. Also it comes in max 4 so its gotta be good :lol:

Does anybody have experience with the 425?
 
#9 ·
TT for me.... if you have a cabelas close by check out their bargin cave in person bc they always have factory refurbs for about half price with a warranty.
 
#10 ·
Ended up going with a sportdog 425. I just ordered one off ebay, seems like a good one for the money ($170)

O.D.Lid said:
DOGTRA :thumbsup: sportdog is junk at least this is what I've heard from former owners
The reviews I see say the 400 had flaws, but the 425 is much better. Time will tell.
 
#11 ·
AB_Gunner said:
Ended up going with a sportdog 425. I just ordered one off ebay, seems like a good one for the money ($170)

O.D.Lid said:
DOGTRA :thumbsup: sportdog is junk at least this is what I've heard from former owners
The reviews I see say the 400 had flaws, but the 425 is much better. Time will tell.
not trying tell you what to do but you had alot of good comments for tri tronics and you still went with the sport dog. for about $20 more you could have gotten the garmin delta sport and could have gotten alot better collar just in distance. I say this because 300 yards makes a big difference when you are talking about hills, dense trees or anything that can block a signal. also alot of the reviews i have seen for the SD 400 where the corrections were very slow they may have fixed that issue but if im correcting a dog i want it to happen when i want it to happen not a second later and something i would not want to worry about. if you want to train the highest level, you want a collar with as many options as possible. that is one reason i want to get a flyway transmitter cause then i can make level changes as needed quickly with out having to look at the transmitter to get the desired response that i want.
 
#13 ·
Well I ordered the sportdog yesterday afternoon before anyone commented. I found a garmin delta sport local to me, so I have cancelled the sportdog order (hopefully he hasnt shipped yet!) I did not know Garmin had bought out tri tronics,
 
#14 ·
I managed to get a refund on the sportdog and went with the garmin delta sport. I have been slowly introducing my dog to the e collar with basic commands. What kind of settings are you guys typically running on the delta sport to get a response out of the dog? My settings seem high, but she is also a very stubborn dog.
 
#15 ·
Over the years I have had three Tri Tronics collars 100 LR, 500 LS, and now a 500 G3 exp. All still work and very few shop repairs. I also have 4 bird release systems that have to be 15 years old and use them for training all summer with no shop time to speak of. TT/Garmin all the way, spend what you can afford their products are great no matter the model.
Teach Train Test andHunt
Wayne
 
#16 ·
AB_Gunner said:
I managed to get a refund on the sportdog and went with the garmin delta sport. I have been slowly introducing my dog to the e collar with basic commands. What kind of settings are you guys typically running on the delta sport to get a response out of the dog? My settings seem high, but she is also a very stubborn dog.
When collar conditioning, you have to be watching for a response in the dog. Usually an ear switch, scratching at the collar, head down etc. Usually a yelp means you are beyond where you are supposed to. I'm not sure of the settings on that collar/transmitter, so I can't help as far as that goes.
 
#17 ·
My sportdog just crapped out, doesn't transmit past 5 yards now. I've used it for 6-8 months light preseason condition for his first season. Now i'm hunting him without a e collar because its broken, and i can't prove my receipt to get it warrantied. Their customer service was excellent, but i'd rather never need a companies customer service. I will go with a different company on this next go around, and keep my receipt. :thumbsup: